Posterity Systems
Menu ☰

Creative Work and Contractor Status: Two 2026 Fair Work Commission Decisions

ReceiptLogic / Public Records Office · Research Batch 21 · Sources inspected November 11, 2026 · Two distinct proceedings, two people

This edition adds two Australian Fair Work Commission decisions that directly document independent creative work: a freelance graphic designer and a media-production professional. They are useful status comparisons, not unpaid-invoice judgments, detention cases, or findings about psychiatric or legal decision-making capacity. The question in each proceeding was whether the person was an employee for a particular Fair Work Act remedy, assessed against the actual relationship and the relevant statutory threshold.

In this study

Hazal Bulut Senel v Swann Communications Pty Ltd — freelance graphic design across two engagements

Fair Work Commission · [2026] FWC 904 · U2025/16223 · Commissioner Yilmaz · decision March 19, 2026; hearing February 20, 2026. The applicant sought an unfair-dismissal remedy under s.394. He said he had worked as a full-time graphic designer from October 16, 2023 to September 18, 2025, and that the May-to-July 2025 break was a temporary pause rather than an end to employment.

Applicant's case, as recorded: He said his work substantially resembled that of employed graphic designers, his hours were regular, he received a company laptop and used internal systems, managers gave design instructions, work was allocated through Trello, and a reference/job-description document supported his position. He relied on the practical appearance of integration and continuity.

Respondent's case, as recorded: Swann said it engaged him as a freelancer on two separate occasions: October 16, 2023 to May 30, 2025, and July 24, 2025 to September 19, 2025. It said work depended on project demand and internal capacity; he could accept or decline projects, had no exclusivity, invoiced at AU$66.60 per hour including GST, was paid fortnightly rather than through employee payroll, received no PAYG withholding or leave, and bore his own business expenses. It also said contractors used company devices and security systems. On the reference and migration documents, the respondent said the applicant drafted them and that the documents described him as a freelancer; the Commission considered them but did not treat them as conclusive of employment.

Commission's finding: The Commission preferred the respondent's evidence on the disputed continuity and control points. It found the first engagement ended on May 30, 2025; the second was a distinct, short 7–8 week freelance engagement, not a temporary pause. It treated the laptop and security controls as non-determinative because contractors also used them. Applying s.15AA and the totality of the relationship, it found the applicant was an independent contractor, not an employee, and dismissed the unfair-dismissal application. It also observed that, even if he were an employee, the separate second engagement would not meet the minimum employment period.

Separate superannuation point: After the hearing, the applicant raised a superannuation contribution. The Commission said s.12(3) of the Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 can treat a person working wholly or principally for labour as an employee for that Act, but that definition does not apply more broadly to the Fair Work Act. This is a statute-specific distinction, not a universal declaration about every legal entitlement.

Appeal status: The reproduced decision carries a note that an appeal under s.604 was lodged as C2026/4672. No later appeal disposition was located in the sources checked on November 11, 2026. The appeal's outcome is therefore left open.

Sources: Fair Work Commission signed decision [2026] FWC 904 (official endpoint; direct retrieval returned HTTP 403 in this check); secondary full-text transcription and case index. The transcription records the appeal note, the parties' competing evidence, and the Commission's reasons at paragraphs [1]–[58].

Daniel De Silva v 75 688 174 585 Pty Ltd — media production, invoices and payroll records

Fair Work Commission · [2026] FWC 765 · C2025/9597 · Commissioner Connolly · decision March 6, 2026; hearing December 16, 2025. The applicant brought a general-protections application involving dismissal under s.365. He said he had been engaged as Head of Production on an annual salary of AU$150,000 plus superannuation and a performance bonus. He relied on payslips, PAYG deductions, superannuation entries and the way the arrangement had been presented.

Other recorded evidence: The decision records an initial AU$1,500 invoice for video-production services under the applicant's ABN, and his evidence that he received that and other payments. He brought existing clients and substantial production equipment, valued in the evidence at about AU$250,000, and exercised significant autonomy over client relationships and work. The respondent said the arrangement allowed the applicant to operate his own business through a separate company and retain client revenue after compliance costs. The parties had no clear written agreement and disagreed about what they had understood.

Commission's finding: The Commission found no sufficiently clear contemporaneous agreement on employment terms. Considering the totality and practical performance, it found the applicant operated with substantial autonomy, brought and serviced his own clients, used his own equipment, and was not substantively integrated into the respondent's business. It held that he was an independent contractor, not an employee; accordingly, he had not been dismissed within s.386 and the Commission lacked jurisdiction to determine the general-protections dismissal application. The application was dismissed on that threshold ground, not after a merits finding on every asserted workplace-right issue.

ATO referral: The decision states that the Commission would refer evidence concerning both parties to the Australian Taxation Office. A referral is not an ATO assessment, a finding of tax liability, a criminal charge, or a conviction. No later ATO determination is included in this record.

Payroll evidence clarification · November 11, 2026: The respondent alleged that Ms Oz and Mr De Silva conspired to create false payslips and make unauthorised payments. The Commissioner accepted Ms Oz's evidence that she created the payroll record and processed wage and superannuation payments under instructions from Mr and Mrs McGarry, and found Mr McGarry's contrary account implausible. The Commission later treated payslips, invoices and bank statements as neutral indicators in the overall worker-status analysis. The decision does not find that Mr De Silva conspired to fabricate payslips. This evidentiary finding is distinct from the FWC-recorded admission by Mr McGarry about false ATO records and from the final independent-contractor classification. See paragraphs [43]–[45] and [72].

Source clarification · November 11, 2026: The reproduced decision records Mr McGarry's sworn admission that he knowingly filed false records with the ATO. At paragraphs [46]–[47], the Commissioner treated that admission as significant and said a referral was required. At [87]–[89], the Commission also resolved to refer Mr De Silva separately, while expressly noting that he had made no admission of comparable significance and making an adverse observation about the consistency of his evidence. These are FWC findings about evidence and referrals; they are not an ATO assessment, criminal charge, conviction, or finding of criminal guilt. No subsequent ATO disposition was verified. The earlier referral summary is retained and clarified here.

Later status: No later appeal disposition was located in the sources checked on November 11, 2026. This is not proof that no appeal or later proceeding exists.

Sources: Fair Work Commission signed decision [2026] FWC 765 (official endpoint; direct retrieval returned HTTP 403 in this check); secondary full-text transcription and case index; Human Resources Director report, March 17, 2026. The secondary transcription records the decision at paragraphs [1]–[89].

What these decisions establish — and what they do not

Worker status: Both decisions applied the Fair Work Act's employee-status test to the totality of each particular relationship. Section 15AA directs attention to the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship, including both contractual terms and how the work was performed. Neither a contractor label nor one isolated indicator such as a company laptop, invoice, payslip or superannuation contribution resolves every case.

Different statutory purposes: The Senel decision expressly separates the Fair Work Act test from the Superannuation Guarantee Act's s.12(3) deeming rule. A person can fall within a statute-specific superannuation definition without that answer automatically determining employee status under a different statute. The particular right and statute must be identified.

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s.15AA; Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth), s.12(3). The FWC decisions themselves remain the source for how those provisions were applied in each proceeding.

Legal capacity and health: Neither proceeding assessed psychiatric diagnosis, mental health, decision-making ability, guardianship, legal capacity, or any form of psychiatric detention. Employee/contractor classification for a specific Fair Work Act remedy is not a functional legal-capacity determination.

Payment and custody: Neither proceeding adjudicated an unpaid freelance invoice or awarded unpaid wages. Neither records arrest, civil contempt, criminal imprisonment, historical debtors' imprisonment, migration detention, forced labour, or psychiatric detention. The evidence does not support a causal chain from an unpaid-work complaint to health reframing or custody.

Count and denominator: This is two proceedings involving two people. It is a selected judgment sample, not a census of freelancers or designers. No population prevalence or worldwide frequency can be inferred.

Deduplication, access and limitations

A name-and-citation scan of the current published ReceiptLogic module found no prior match for either person, proceeding number or citation in the existing B08–B20 collection and related public index material. These are two additive proceedings, not new custody events. Earlier research bodies, corrections, private Nurture entries and permissions are not rewritten.

The official Fair Work Commission signed-decision endpoints are linked above, but direct retrieval returned HTTP 403 during this source check. The case details were checked against the secondary full-text transcriptions and the independent Human Resources Director report for De Silva. The secondary database is not the issuing tribunal; the official source remains the authoritative record. The appeal outcome in C2026/4672 and any later ATO disposition were not verified. This batch does not resolve global coverage, non-English court archives, or the broader causal research question.

Metadata correction: The secondary database listing displays a generic January 1, 2026 date field for both matters, while the reproduced decision bodies state March 19, 2026 for Senel and March 6, 2026 for De Silva. This edition uses the decision-body dates, not the listing placeholder.

Research access date: November 11, 2026 (Pacific). This edition is an additive public comparison; it creates no private Nurture native entry and makes no diagnosis, incapacity, guilt, motive, prevalence or causal inference.

Related research

Return to the Public Records Office
The public record belongs in view.