Posterity Systems
Menu ☰

Independent Work and Contract Labels: Five Status Decisions

ReceiptLogic public research · Batch 18 · UK, EU and Australia · sources inspected November 9, 2026 (Pacific).

A contractor label, employment-tax classification, statutory worker status, payment order and a person's legal capacity answer different questions. Five distinct judicial matters below are compared by their actual legal scope. Only the first involves an independently documented freelance television creative professional. None proves a chain from unpaid design work to a psychiatric label or confinement.

In this study

B18-01 · Hall v Lorimer — freelance television work

In 1993 the UK Court of Appeal treated a freelance television vision mixer as self-employed for the tax issue. Mr Lorimer served about 20–22 production companies across many short engagements, despite using studio equipment. This is an official government summary, not independently retrieved original appellate reasons. Neither a missing fee nor a health or custody determination was at issue. HMRC case summary (updated October 7, 2026).

B18-02 · Pimlico Plumbers v Smith — limited substitution

The UK Supreme Court dismissed the company's status appeal on June 13, 2018 ([2018] UKSC 29). Restricted substitution and personal-service obligations supported a statutory worker finding for specified claims, despite contractor language, freedom to reject some work and some financial risk. The ruling permitted wage, leave and discrimination claims to proceed; it did not decide those merits or document payment. A dispute about a discrimination claim is not a clinical or legal-capacity finding. Official case; Supreme Court summary.

B18-03 · IWGB v CAC and Deliveroo — union-recognition route

On November 21, 2023 the UK Supreme Court dismissed the union's appeal ([2023] UKSC 43). The CAC had found that genuinely substitutable riders were outside the worker definition for the particular compulsory collective-bargaining route. The union advanced Article 11 arguments; Deliveroo defended the non-personal-service arrangements. This is not a general ban on union membership, a finding that no rider can have rights, or an adjudication of an unpaid invoice. Official judgment with arguments.

B18-04 · B v Yodel Delivery Network — conditional EU order

On April 22, 2020 the Court of Justice issued a preliminary order (C-692/19) about Working Time Directive status. Real freedoms to substitute, decline tasks, serve competitors and set hours may be inconsistent with worker status, but only if independence is not fictitious and the relationship is not subordinate. The national tribunal, not the EU order, had to resolve the actual facts. No final domestic payment or detention result was obtained. Official EUR-Lex operative order.

B18-05 · CFMMEU v Personnel Contracting — label versus rights

On February 9, 2022 Australia's High Court held a labor-hire worker to be an employee despite a written self-employed contractor label ([2022] HCA 1); remaining issues were remitted. This was a construction engagement, not freelance design, and not a back-pay collection receipt. Critically, covered relationships in Australia are now subject to Fair Work Act s15AA's real-substance and practical-reality test introduced August 26, 2024; the 2022 approach must not be stated as unchanged 2026 law. Official High Court record; Fair Work Ombudsman 2024 change.

Practical record and limits

Preserve the promised fee, actual deliverables, dated invoices, remittances, approved scope, substitutions, decisions on work hours and each party's contemporaneous written account. A worker-status ruling is not a wage receipt; a permitted claim is not an award; an award is not collected money. Economic hardship is not a finding of illness or inability to decide. The ILO Employment Relationship Recommendation No. 198 provides international policy guidance on disguised employment, not an individual verdict. Opposing accounts and jurisdictional differences remain part of the record.

Research limit: The cases are five different litigated matters, not a representative sample, not five unpaid freelancer invoices, and not incarcerations. Original Hall judgment, later claim outcomes and all payment receipts were not obtained; EU Yodel is a reference rather than the domestic outcome. No diagnosis, guilt, causation, motive or incidence rate is inferred. Earlier ReceiptLogic research, private Nurture originals and corrections are preserved.

Related research

Return to the Public Records Office
The public record belongs in view.